Friday, September 20, 2019

The Jewish Link welcomes letters to the editor, which can be emailed to [email protected]
Letters may be edited for length, clarity and appropriateness. We do not welcome personal attacks or disrespectful language, and replies to letters through our website comment feed will not be posted online. We reserve the right to not print any letter.

As a veteran of the IDF I have taken the same oath or affirmation that all IDF soldiers take, to protect and defend the Jewish people at the cost of my own life if necessary.

I am also a USMC kid (though I haven’t looked like a kid for many years) and an IDF dad with children and a grandchild living in the land of Israel.

Therefore, one may find it unusual to find me siding with (I don’t know what kind of) Jewish Voices for Peace and favoring the presentation of “P Is for Palestine” by openly anti-Semitic author (and Rutgers University professor) Golbarg Bashi. (“Highland Park Library Stops Short of Canceling Event With Author of ‘P Is for Palestine,’” May 9, 2019).

My opinion is informed by history. As Adolf Hitler was invading Poland, the English-language translation of “Mein Kampf,” scrubbed of its grosser ideas including what would become the Holocaust, was about to be published in the United States. An informed young journalist, Alan Cranston (who would later become a U.S. senator) worked with the Anti-Defamation League and the American Jewish Congress to publish a version without the abridgment so that no one could be excused by claiming they did not know what Hitler’s plans were. Unfortunately, the full impact of their publication was diminished. The pernicious lie, that what would happen to the Jews and the world for that matter if Hitler were to succeed was not foreseeable, persists to this day.

So by all means present this kiddie Mein Kampf, “P is for Palestine,” so no one can claim that they are unaware of the violent anti-Semitic indoctrination of Palestinian children that takes place with the encouragement of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency and the Palestinian Authority.

Highland Park Public Library is not, however, without criticism. If the idea was to present a view of Islam in honor of the month of Ramadan, they have failed. [Despite] all the contributions that have been made through Islam’s over 1000-year history, currently nearly 25% of the world’s population have chosen to present Islam as child-abusing terrorists. Their action has caused the Highland Park Public Library to be guilty of both the new hatred of Islamophobia and the oldest hatred of anti-Semitism. For this all those involved in this decision need to be separated from the Highland Park Library summarily and forever. Great shame has been brought upon an otherwise noble, diverse and tolerant pillar of Highland Park’s social fabric.

Zev Rosenberg